9/11, Independent Institute and 20 Years of the “War on Terror”
Literally on 9/11/01 and throughout the 20 culture-destroying years since, the Independent Institute has stood hard and fast for the difficult but essential principles that undergird liberty, human dignity, and the rule of law.
While many whom we had thought shared our devotion to liberty were doing things like removing the word “Peace” from their mastheads and calling for “sand to be turned into silicon,” (that is, nuking the desert countries), we were among the precious few responsible voices calling for responses in accordance with peaceful, prosperous and free societies, grounded in a commitment to human worth and dignity.
Here’s a recap of some of those efforts:
- 9/11/2001: In the immediate, real-time unfolding of the horrific events in New York, and despite even some internal dissent that we speak out, Independent’s founder and president David J. Theroux led the way in our drafting and posting to Independent’s home page a statement denouncing the terrorist attacks and urging that they not be allowed to be used as fodder for new government powers. It was later edited and issued as a News Release.
- Independent issues a call for the issuance of the Constitutionally-provided Letters of Marque and Reprisal for the capture of Osama bin Laden and his associates, dead or alive—a task it subsequently took the U.S. military 10 years to accomplish. Rep. Ron Paul later introduced H.R.3076: The September 11 Marque and Reprisal Act of 2001 in Congress.
Imagine the savings in liberty, lives, and fortunes spent in the fruitless occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan.
- Independent established the Center on Peace and Liberty, hiring Ivan Eland as its Director and Charles V. Peña, as well as working with many others in furthering the principles of liberty against calls for increased government powers at home and abroad.
Because of our unique voice questioning invasive, unconstitutional wars, our Fellows regularly garnered major media coverage, including on ABC, PBS, CNN, CNBC, Fox, C-SPAN, and more.
In the spring of 2002, we organized the first, major, national event to challenge the “War on Terror,” with a sold-out audience of over 1,000 (we even had scalpers!), held in San Francisco’s Herbst Theater:
Understanding America’s Terrorist Crisis: What Should Be Done?, featured Gore Vidal, Lewis H. Lapham, and a panel of discussants: Barton J. Bernstein (Stanford University), Robert Higgs (Senior Fellow, Independent Institute), and Thomas Gale Moore (Hoover Institution)
In conjunction with the event, the San Francisco Chronicle ran an op-ed adapted from Gore Vidal’s then new book, Perpetual War for Perpetual Peace: The New War on Freedom : Give me liberty, or give me . . . what? Security?
Before and subsequent to this, we organized an ongoing series of events, many covered by C-SPAN:
Why Freedom Matters More Than Ever, with David R. Henderson
Big Brother is Watching, with James Bamford, Author of Body of Secrets: Anatomy of the Ultra-Secret National Security Agency
The U.S. War on Terrorism: Myths and Realities, with Lewis H. Lapham, Alan W. Bock, J. Victor Marshall, Seth Rosenfeld, and Paul H. Weaver
Secrecy, Freedom and Empire: Lessons for Today from Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers, with Daniel Ellsberg and a panel of discussants, held at the University of California, Berkeley
Preemptive War Strategy: A New U.S. Empire?, with Joel S. Beinin, Edward A. Olson, and Ivan Eland
PATRIOT Acts: I & II: The New Assault on Liberty?, with Ivan Eland, David Cole (Georgetown University) Margaret Russell (ACLU), and James Bovard
Terrorism and Iraq: What is the Nature of the Relationship? A Debate, with Don Smith, Stephen Hayes, Walter Russell Mead, and Ivan Eland
The Future of Iraq: Democracy or Quagmire?, with George Bisharat, Ivan Eland, James H. Noyes, and Christopher Scheer
Against Leviathan: Government Power and a Free Society, with Robert Higgs
The Empire Has No Clothes: U.S. Foreign Policy Exposed, with Ivan Eland
How—And How Not—To Fight Terrorism, with Michael Scheuer
In 2005, we held a 2-day conference at the Willard Hotel in Washington, The War on Terror: Implications for Domestic Security and Civil Liberties, with Ron Paul as the keynote speaker.
In 2006, we opened an office in DuPont Circle in Washington, DC, with Independent fellows Ivan Eland, Alvaro Vargas Llosa, and Gabriel Gasave moving there. The building was a former mansion with a ballroom very well suited to holding frequent events and we pursued a series of bi-coastal events both there and in the Bay Area:
Innovative Solutions for Iraq: Independent Policy Forum & Open House Reception
How to Really Win the War on Terrorism, with Charles V. Peña, Roger W. Cressey, and Joseph Cirincione
The Reality and Legacy of the Iraq War, with Ivan Eland and Mark Danner
Living With a Nuclear Iran and North Korea?, with Ivan Eland, Charles V. Peña, Trita Parsi, and Doug Bandow
Troop Withdrawal: Looking Beyond Iraq, with Ivan Eland, Leon T. Hadar, and David R. Henderson
New Directions for Peace and Security, with Carl P. Close, Jeffrey Rogers Hummel, James L. Payne, and Edward P. Stringham
A series of events on our book, Twilight War: The Folly of U.S. Space Dominance, by Mike M. Moore (former Editor, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists).
Why Are Politicians Always Trying to Scare Us?, with Robert Higgs
Is the “War on Terror” Creating Terrorism?, with Ian S. Lustick, Ivan Eland, and D. Gareth Porter
Bush, Obama, and Presidential Power, with Ivan Eland, Ron Paul, and Richard Shenkman
Can the U.S. Withdraw from Afghanistan and Iraq?, with Ivan Eland, Peter Galbraith, and Charles V. Peña
Civil Liberties and Security in an Age of Terrorism, with Robert Higgs, Anthony Gregory, and Mary L. G. Theroux
Liberty Defined: The Future of Freedom, with Ron Paul
Whither America: A Foreign Policy Debate Among Realists, Nationalists and Internationalists, with Ivan Eland, Michael Lind, and Harry Nau
Liberty and 21st-Century Thought Control , with Edward P. Stringham, Jeffrey Tucker, Richard K. Vedder, Williamson M. Evers, Wen Fa, David J. Theroux, and Patrick Reasonover
Which brings us to 9/11’s spawn: the “Coronacrisis” and our many virtual events over the past 18 months, starting 3 days following the declared “3-week” shutdown:
Fear: The Fuel of Government Power—Coronavirus Panic, with Graham H. Walker, Mary L. G. Theroux
Corona Crisis and Leviathan, with Graham H. Walker and Mary L. G. Theroux
How to Restore Freedom to Americans in This Time of Pandemic?, with Graham H. Walker and Randall G. Holcombe
Civil Liberties and the Surveillance State, with Mary L. G. Theroux and Erich J. Prince
In addition, Independent produced numerous books, policy reports, and many articles in The Independent Review and online.
Against Leviathan: Government Power and a Free Society, by Robert Higgs
The Empire Has No Clothes: U.S. Foreign Policy Exposed, by Ivan Eland
Resurgence of the Warfare State: The Crisis Since 9/11, by Robert Higgs
Neither Liberty nor Safety: Fear, Ideology, and the Growth of Government, by Robert Higgs
Opposing the Crusader State: Alternatives to Global Interventionism, edited by Carl P. Close and Robert Higgs
Twilight War: The Folly of U.S. Space Dominance, by Mike M. Moore
Partitioning for Peace: An Exit Strategy for Iraq, by Ivan Eland
Depression, War, and Cold War: Challenging the Myths of Conflict and Prosperity, by Robert Higgs
The Civilian and the Military: A History of the American Antimilitarist Tradition, by Arthur A. Ekirch, Jr., with a foreword by Ralph Raico
No War for Oil: U.S. Dependency and the Middle East, by Ivan Eland
Delusions of Power: New Explorations of the State, War, and Economy, by Robert Higgs
Crisis and Leviathan: Critical Episodes in the Growth of American Government (25th Anniversary Edition), by and with a new preface by Robert Higgs
American Surveillance: Intelligence, Privacy, and the Fourth Amendment, by Anthony Gregory
War and the Rogue Presidency: Restoring the Republic after Congressional Failure, by Ivan Eland
Liberty in Peril: Democracy and Power in American History, by Randall G. Holcombe, with a foreword by Barry R. Weingast
The Independent Review articles (partial list)
By Robert Higgs:
- Government Protects Us? (Fall 2002)
- Fear: The Foundation of Every Government’s Power (Winter 2005/06)
- On “Winning the War” (Summer 2006)
- Caging the Dogs of War: How Major U.S. Neoimperialist Wars End (Fall 2008)
- To Fight or Not to Fight: War’s Payoffs to U.S. Leaders and to the American People (Summer 2011)
- Are Questions of War and Peace Merely One Issue among Many for Libertarians? (Fall 2011)
- “War Is Horrible, but . . .” (Fall 2012)
- Moderation in Response to Provocation Is No Vice (Summer 2017)
Perfecting Tyranny: Foreign Intervention as Experimentation in State Control, by Christopher J. Coyne and Abigail Hall Blanco
And of course our the symposium in the current issue (Fall 2021): 20 Years of the “War on Terror”
And for a little light relief: Episode 5 of Love Gov: From First Date to Mandate; and as a running theme in Love Gov2: A Crisis Not to Waste.
For those of us who thought we “knew” the “facts” behind 9/11 and subsequent events, I commend to you the recent article by Senior Fellow Angelo M. Codevilla, “Graveyard of Narratives: Afghanistan, et al., for the record,” for an insider’s exposé of the false narratives behind the “War on Terror.”
The real legacy has been the deterioration of American’s traditional attitudes in support of liberty and checks on government power. The following surveys, taken just before and after 9/11, capture some of these dramatic changes at the time:
All has now led to today, and the attempt to mold a new generation to fear and hate “others;” reject Truth, Goodness, Science, and Beauty; and be submissive citizens to an almighty, paternalistic State.
There is nothing that would have made me happier than us not having been right. And of course, the ground had been prepared well in advance, with many decades of pervasive U.S. policies of global interventionism and coercive “nation building,” creating a huge, domestic military-industrial-congressional complex of massive waste and corporate welfare. Internationally, such measures were propping up corrupt and brutal regimes, provoking deep resentments, and helping to foster dangerous, anti-Western, terrorist movements. With 9/11, instead of holding accountable those specific individuals responsible for the massive deaths and destruction in New York and Virginia, the Washington establishment tripled and quadrupled down by launching even more interventionism and nation building but to a far greater extent.
Tragically, everything we warned about above has since come to pass: massive numbers of deaths and maimings, trillions of dollars misspent, runaway government spending and debt, extensive political and special-interest pork and corruption, negation of constitutional rights, including the loss of any expectation of privacy, and much more. This list is too long and too painful to enumerate.
The good news is that today, most people are increasingly coming to learn the hard lessons of this sorry misadventure and folly of the “War on Terror.”
The bad news is that virtually none of the measures that could be undone have yet been and are unlikely to be without our discrediting the scam involved. Leviathan and its beneficiaries love the new powers and they will not give up on their own.
Who is with us?